Jeffrey Smith, founding director of Washington-based advocacy group Vanguard Africa, offered a scathing critique of the proposed deal.
“Deporting immigrants to Rwanda is both morally and legally reprehensible. At its core, the plan is simply inhumane, while also being a violation of long-existing international human rights laws and agreements,” Smith tells The Africa Report.
“The Kagame dictatorship has repeatedly shown itself to not be a reliable, good-faith international partner. It has done so, for instance, by politicising the issue of refugee and immigrant rights, portraying itself as a benign third party, when in fact this is merely a ploy to garner positive headlines and a cynical way in which to compel Western governments, like the US, to look the other way when human rights abuses are committed.”
Smith’s comments reflect broader concerns among rights advocates, who argue that the outsourcing of deportations to countries with questionable human rights records risks legitimising authoritarian governance under the guise of migration management.